Circuit Training: A More Effective Tool For Body Re-Composition

The typical person at the gym who wants to “lose a little weight and tone up” may spend a lot of time doing cardio (to burn calories) and then gets off the machine to do a bit of aimless resistance training.  He or she will say, “Then I do, you know, some biceps, triceps, chest, shoulders, and some of these thingies,” and then will awkwardly demonstrate some kind of frontal or sagittal plane motion.

“How many sets and reps do you do?” I’ll ask.

Usually 1 or 2 sets of 10.

If it’s a woman, she probably doesn’t want to “bulk up.”

Interesting, since a set range of 1 to 3 sets, and a rep range of 8-12 reps is what causes hypertrophy (in Greek, hyper means “excess” and trophy means “nourishment”), that is, an increase in the volume of tissue.  Hypertrophy causes muscles to grow bigger–to “bulk up.”

“Toning up,” on the other hand, means having more visible muscle definition; it means burning the fat off the top.

Theoretically, in order to tone up, one would want to burn as many calories as possible in order to lose pounds of fat.  One should probably dedicate more time to cardio–which burns the most calories–and less time to resistance training, right?

Wrong.  And this is the mistake I see people making over and over and over again at the gym.  It’s usually women, too.

Cardio, as defined by personal training textbooks, is defined by any activity performed on a machine designed to maintain an elevated heart rate: ellipticals, treadmills/running, stair-steppers, etc.  Cardiovascular fitness is essential for health, as it trains the heart (the body’s most essential muscle), increases stroke volume, VO2 max, cardiac output, oxidative capacity of muscles, and it also decreases both resting and exercising heart rates.

But cadio, as defined by me, is any activity that keeps the heart rate elevated period.  After all, that is how the heart gets trained.  It doesn’t care what kind of activity you’re doing.

Circuit training is perhaps the most beneficial form of cardiorespiratory training out there.  Circuit training is basically a series of resistance training exercises performed one after another, with minimal rest in between.  Resistance training, we know, is also a very important component of a balanced fitness program, and the benefits of it are numerous: increased bone mineral density, increased strength, increased range of activities and motion, improved mobility, improved stability, and more.

  • Circuit training breaks the body out of the traditional, limiting movement patterns and required the body to change position and direction often.  This burns more calories than maintaining the same direction of movement.  It also dynamically improves an individual’s range of motion and flexibility.
  • Circuits can combine different intensities of exercises, rep ranges, and times with extreme ease, enabling the individual to target higher or lower heart rates during activity.
  • Circuits can be designed with hypertrophy or muscular endurance in mind, depending on the individual’s goals.
  • Circuits allow for “active recovery.”  For example, after working the legs by doing squats, the individual can switch to a non-competing exercise.
  • Circuits more easily elevate heart rate and oxygen consumption.  Because of active recovery, its easier to maintain a higher heart rate throughout the workout by switching to another muscle group before the first group reaches its lactic acid threshold.  Higher intensity leads to higher EPOC, which leads to more calorie burn outside of the gym.
  • A circuit can be designed to work any part of the body that has the energy to exercise.
  • Circuit training is cross training.
  • Circuit training is cardiovascular, resistance, and dynamic range of motion training in one.  Think “cardio weight lifting with improvements in flexibility.”

Why wouldn’t you circuit train?  Try it.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

How To Lose Fat

I had a good laugh reading about muscle gain and fat burning.

Will More Muscle Rev Up Your Metabolism?  The answer, from Marticia Heaner in “Triggering Your Body To Burn Fat”, was short and sweet.  “Probably not.”

Most personal trainers, including myself, tell others that building muscle is one of the best uses of time at the gym.  It is metabolically more active tissue, it is denser.  When you build muscle, you tend to lower your body fat percentage

…but in terms of losing fat, objectively.  Well, building muscle guarantees nothing.

Why?  Because to build muscle, you have to eat.  And you tend to eat a lot.  You will likely overeat, as muscle is hungry, and building it makes you tired.  That marginal metabolic edge conferred through muscle gain is often eclipsed by an over-compensation in eating.

I know this first hand.  If you’re like me, and exercise is easy, but fat is stubborn, your problem is probably food.  Plain and simple.

Sure, a lot can be said (by me, especially) about efficiency in exercise.  If you have a small amount of time, you’re aim should be to burn the most energy possible, get the highest afterburn, and build the most muscle.  Easy, right?  Yeah… not really.  But that’s content for a different article.

I can tell my readers first hand that putting on lots of muscle will not necessarily make you lose body fat.  What often happens is you become a larger, stronger version of your fat self! What to do?

Fat loss, according to every credible article, is not scientific.  It is an annoying, objective numbers game.  Move more, eat less.  Burn more than you eat.  Period.  It does not matter what type of energy you burn.  If you write down every calorie honestly and prove you are creating a deficit of 3,500 calories, but fail to lose a pound of fat… then maybe, just maybe you have a thyroid problem.  But I’d wager that 99% of thyroid problems are simply denial.

Eat less.  Bottom line.  Eat less. Front load your calories in the beginning of the day, taper toward the evening, and if you go to bed a little bit hungry (a little, not a lot!), you’re probably on the path to body fat loss.

Increase your total movement, not necessarily your exercise.  Lift too many weights, and you might get too hungry to stick to your lower calorie diet.  Take trips by foot, park the car far away, clean things by hand, pace around, whatever you have to do.

Here we go again: move more, eat less.

Gravitate Towards Challenge

When you enter the gym, you see a lot of people doing a lot of different things.  Most of them, however, are riding the elliptical machines, jogging on the treadmill, doing ab exercises on the floor, and sculpting their chests and biceps with free weights… Typical.

Typical, and easy.

People like to gravitate toward what is easy.  The elliptical machine, for example, is easy.  It’s no impact, fluid, and has a TV attached to it.  The ab crunching machine… easy.  Just rock back and forth, levering your body weight into the gadget.  The weight stack machines, too, are easy.  Sit down, adjust the pin, and press.  No need to stabilize yourself.  Biceps curls… easy.  Sit, watch yourself in the mirror, and lift a relatively small weight with a small muscle.

Every now and then, you see someone doing something ridiculous, like busting out 50 double unders with a jump rope after having already done 100 squats; oh yeah, and they’re doing it six times in a row!  That’s hard, and its exhausting.  Some people can pick up more than their body weight, can do pullups with weights chained to them, and do pushups with their feet in the air, against a wall.  Nine times out of ten, these people have ridiculous bodies to match the ridiculousness of their workouts.  The 10% that don’t are probably on their way; not everyone makes it, though.

Injury is one thing that stops progress when you embrace challenging exercise.

Mindset, or attitude, is the other big culprit.

Don’t trick yourself into thinking you have worked hard the day before, and are entitled to some rest and some cookies.  That’s easy.

Challenge yourself daily.  Once you’re accustomed to a particular work load, add to it. Already have the exercise figured out?  Then figure out the diet!

Your body is smarter than your brain.  Your brain will tell you a lot, mostly trying to find ways to preserve your ego, and to make things easier.  It tells you to quit, it tells you to feel sorry for yourself.  Your brain can easily sabotage the progress of your body.  Make your body tell your brain to shut up. (Of course, I’m not a dualist, but it’s fun to talk about these entities as conflicting.)

Stop feeling sorry for yourself.  Put your brain to work by thinking up new challenges.  Write down what you are going to do at the gym before you step onto the floor.  Stick to it.  Finish it, no matter what.

Your Body As A Project

I was at Barnes and Noble, scouring the cultural studies section (the goldmine for books about our current food system and food culture), when I stumbled upon a little book called Bodies, by Susie Orbach.  I didn’t have to read the back to know it would sing to me, as my profession deals with helping other people change their bodies.

Orbach makes many very striking observations about culture expressing itself through people’s bodies, and how everything from body language, to tattoos, to fashion, to personal space, to comforting touch is a result of an over-arching body culture.  Today, more than ever before, our bodies are in the forefront of culture (not merely subtly embedded in it).

You see fashion magazines, weight loss shows, billboards, commercials, super make-over shows, models, mannequins, athletes, posters, cosmetics, hair dyes, razors, tweezers, protein powders, skin creams, oh-Jesus-the-list-goes-on-and-on, ad infinitum… everything on the market seems to be some kind of body altering scheme or device.

What happened?  When?  Why did we become so body obsessed?

Her answer (or at least what I surmised): the body was once a tool for production.  We used to wash our own dishes, make our own clothes, dig our own holes, mow our own lawns… and then technology got the best of us.

We’ve all heard this before.  Of course labor-saving technology altered the course of our lives.

But it also altered the course of our body culture.

The body, once a tool for production, is now the object of production. We didn’t seem to have any other choice.

Should that be considered so bad?  What’s wrong with being healthy, trying to look good, trying to stay young?

Nothing, except you must remember that your body is inescapable.  It is wholly and completely personal to you, and experientially inaccessible to anyone else.  Culture is constructed; it is subjective, somewhat arbitrary, and pliable.  The body, however, is not; it is tangible, measurable, and difficult to alter, especially in trying to keep with the speed of culture.  This inability to conform rapidly enough–if at all–inevitably leads to frustration and stress.

Why do you want to alter your body?  Is it a game?  A cultural experiment?  Is there any practical reason for doing so?

I try to teach others that the body is a vessel.  It has to take you from one point to the next, and endure through time.  It has to work for you.  If it is healthy, it will work well, and you will feel well; don’t think for a moment that body chemistry does not affect brain chemistry.  The two are inextricably linked.

Try to go back in time.  Take a technological step backwards.  Put your body back to work.  Feel how useful it can be.  Make it, once again, an object for production.

Focus On Something Tangible: Your Body

It’s hard booking appointments at the gym these days.  Everyone’s wired in to something.  I remember when the treadmills and elliptical machines came with TVs on them.  I though, “Oh no, we really can’t get away from the TV for even 45 minutes!”  How sad.

Exercise is your time to associate with your body.  To make sure it still functions properly, and that you are using all of its functionality.  But people now, more than ever, are looking for ways to disassociate from the bodies–especially during times they are supposed to associate with them.

When I left the country for two years, I left my phone, and my iPod, and my computer… I left it all.  Best decision I ever made.  I could hear things again, I noticed people’s smiles when I passed them on the street, I wasn’t looking back–only forward.  I returned to the hand-written letter, a far more personal mode of communication than a digital text message.

How unfortunate that in this digital age, one can no longer manage their affairs unless they have internet access, unless they have a phone number.  I had to buy a tiny laptop during my travels just to find volunteer work.

Back in the States, I’m linked back in.  I had to get a new phone, I’m chained to my computer all day (hence, these articles) and I can’t stop thinking about all the stuff I’m reading and seeing on the internet.  I argue that my time on this machine is work-related.  That I don’t play on Facebook/MySpace anymore, that I don’t AOL Instant Message, that I am not reading celebrity gossip or online gaming.  I’m not, but it still feels like too much.

When I can’t talk to people on the gym floor any more, I feel locked out.  Some people put headphones in their ears even without music, just so others will leave them alone.  But why?  Are we so afraid of interacting with people these days?  Do we have such social anxiety?  Can we socialize at all?!

Here’s an article that I found depressing: from the New York Times, “Your Brain On Computers: Hooked on Gadgets, and Paying a Mental Price.”

In summary, bursts of information from electronic sources cause a little spurt of dopamine in our brains.  Highly addictive stuff.  We can’t seem to get enough–internet addiction.  And internet withdrawal.  We come down off of all that dopamine and then what?  Did you know that dopamine is the same stuff that gets people addicted to gambling?  Hard habit to kick, too.

Not only are we “hooked on being linked in,” we’re paying for it.  All this information and multi-tasking was supposed to make us smarter and more productive.  The opposite turns out to be true: our attention spans are shorter, we are highly distracted, and the result is fractured thinking.  We don’t even have the attention span to read full articles any more; our eyes skim the abstracts and excerpts.  Worse, even if we link out and stop all this multi-tasking, our brains are still fractured.  Computers and gadgets are actually re-wiring our brains.

How does this all link back to exercise?  It doesn’t, really.  It just bothers me.  As I said before, exercise is supposed to make you associate with your body.  Leave your tweets and buzzes, books, pads, spaces, and forums at home for just a little while.  Give it a rest, and focus on something tangible: your body.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 48 other followers